Bug Reveals ProgPoW More Asics Friendly Than Current Ethereum Algo

栏目: IT技术 · 发布时间: 5年前

内容简介:“Least Authority [auditors] didn’t catch this; Bob Rao didn’t; IfDefElse [which proposed ProgPoW] didn’t; [researcher] solardiz didn’t, etc.This is a novel method relying on applying BTC’s ability to increment the nonce being applied to ETH. Terrifc find,

“Least Authority [auditors] didn’t catch this; Bob Rao didn’t; IfDefElse [which proposed ProgPoW] didn’t; [researcher] solardiz didn’t, etc.

This is a novel method relying on applying BTC’s ability to increment the nonce being applied to ETH. Terrifc find, well done.”

So says Kristy-Leigh Minehan, the public face of ProgPoW, after confirming the ostensibly asics resistant algorithm that she has been pushing for years is actually not that asics resistant.

“Ethash uses 256-bits for its seed; ProgPoW uses 64-bits (since it makes up for the missing 192-bit elsewhere)…

In Kik’s findings , he found you can simply do the memory hard part once for a single seed, and then find your header + nonce through incrementing the extraNonce field,” says Minehan.

The difference between 64 and 256 might not seem like much, but it’s actually decisive as you can just brute force this key asics resistance component on an ordinary laptop, and then you asics mine the rest.

Astonishingly Minehan says this “bug” means “the higher difficulty is, the more profitable.”

ProgPoW was shelved again recently after it suddenly was “approved” with this bug revealed after it was ditched.

So it isn’t quite clear whether it was an unintentional bug or a well hidden backdoor of sorts to centralized ethereum mining with Minehan stating fixing this would be easy, but if so many missed it, then it’s not clear what else they might have missed.

Minehan herself is an expert in the mining field. She was working for Core Scientific, a huge industrial mining farm for bitcoin asics and ethereum GPUs based in USA.

Minehan was able to kind of hack GPUs, turning them into FPGAs that mine slightly better than normal GPUs.

So perhaps it isn’t too surprising this bug wasn’t found until after ProgPoW was shelved because mining is a very specialized field with very few able to engage in any peer review.

That expectation any new code probably has some bug somewhere and the lack of data on how many asics miners there are on eth, if any at all, was one reason plenty opposed ProgPoW.

$ETH 's nonce space does not present any visible perturbation, but that doesn't mean there's no ASICs running. pic.twitter.com/9roHksxhmu

— Antoine Le Calvez (@khannib) January 7, 2019

As it stands there is no evidence there are proper asics on ethereum, although some claim to be developing them but it’s not clear how much more efficient they would be than GPUs.

Ethereum’s algorithm has been designed to be asics resistant, so maybe there are some potential improvements of 2x or 4x, but nothing like bitcoin where it’s 50x and up.

Had ProgPoW gone through, however, it seems it would have taken off the memory part which is what makes the algo asics resistant, so leaving only the raw calculations bit and thus only the asics.

Copyrights Trustnodes.com


以上就是本文的全部内容,希望对大家的学习有所帮助,也希望大家多多支持 码农网

查看所有标签

猜你喜欢:

本站部分资源来源于网络,本站转载出于传递更多信息之目的,版权归原作者或者来源机构所有,如转载稿涉及版权问题,请联系我们

海量运维、运营规划之道

海量运维、运营规划之道

唐文 / 电子工业出版社 / 2014-1-1 / 59.00

《海量运维、运营规划之道》作者具有腾讯、百度等中国一线互联网公司多年从业经历,书中依托工作实践,以互联网海量产品质量、效率、成本为核心,从规划、速度、监控、告警、安全、管理、流程、预案、考核、设备、带宽等方面,结合大量案例与读者分享了作者对互联网海量运维、运营规划的体会。 《海量运维、运营规划之道》全面介绍大型互联网公司运维工作所涉及的各个方面,是每个互联网运维工程师、架构师、管理人员不可或......一起来看看 《海量运维、运营规划之道》 这本书的介绍吧!

JSON 在线解析
JSON 在线解析

在线 JSON 格式化工具

Base64 编码/解码
Base64 编码/解码

Base64 编码/解码

Markdown 在线编辑器
Markdown 在线编辑器

Markdown 在线编辑器